So, in the last month (give or take a week), two old school, software-based MIDI step sequencers have been released as freeware: Algo Arts’ Bankstep and the Techno Toys suite (actually a suite of 3 sequencers).
Good times. I always find it interesting to see long-absent shareware return from beyond and given away for free. It’s certainly a neighbourly gesture on behalf of the developer, but it also gives us a chance to re-evaluate software rendered obsolete. The spirit of the times is such that technology is more about the next level rather than its current function. That’s why, despite taking five years to supercede XP, Microsoft has been talking about what was to become Vista for nearly that entire time. There always has to be that “this is the future” upgrade hovering at the periphery.
One thing about these step sequencers, all four were modeled on their hardware predecessors. As a result, I think they got a lot of things right, as they do a lot of what you want from a step sequencer without a lot of extra crap. Surprisingly, not many things since then have done as good of a job at capturing the strengths of the lowly step sequencer in the same way. The best MIDI step sequencer VST plugins around right now are either based on the piano roll form or its offshoot, the drum grid. But the steps and sliders aesthetic seems to have been abandoned, and only seems to show up built-in to instruments. Even something like SQ4 and its replacement Matryx, while admirably capturing some of the spirit of the hardware sequencer (and Matryx seems especially trying to be closer to the Notron), it loses the simplicity and usability of the format, like what you find in the 303, or 909, or the Moog-like sequencers, or the arbitrary function generators, or Elektron’s Machinedrum, or FutureRetro’s Mobius/Revolution, or the Korg Electribes, etc.
Those fairly simple step sequencers are popular because they are also effective. Too many sequencers (especially most MIDI tracking DAW things) seem to forget how easy sequencing can be. I’ve long said I despise the piano roll sequencer view, and I still do. I’d rather work with a staff view or hardware-styled step sequencer any day. And sadly the most step sequencer-like DAW thing around, Fruity Loops, really is only useful as a drum sequencer in step mode, and relegates effective control and pitch sequencers to the piano roll. Vaz Modular’s sequencer modules are my favourite, as they’ve integrated the hardware idea well but still take advantage of useful software features (randomize, copy/paste, MIDI input, etc). Too bad they can’t propel other instruments as well, and too bad its song mode arranger is a bit of a pain in the arse to work with, since it’s locked away in a fairly limited and inflexible pop-up screen. There’s another one out there by Gradywerks, but I found it’s MIDI out messages didn’t always work the way I expected them to.
I’ll be making use of BankStep and Seq-303, as I find them handy and have always liked the way they worked. By the time I could comfortably register shareware without worrying about the cost in any way, Seq-303 had already gone AWOL. So in absence of sending a few bucks his way, I hereby send all praise out to the Techno Toys programmer.
Speaking of Microsoft Vista, I haven’t heard much in the way of its MIDI/loopback routing implementation, so I’m guessing they’ve not done anything about it. Which is stupid, surely full open routing between MIDI apps including an effective way to sync everything could be handled best in the OS rather than through add-ons and workarounds.